進階三段邏輯題 - 推理遊戲

By Hedwig
at 2009-07-05T16:35
at 2009-07-05T16:35
Table of Contents
: 前提:
: 1. Some Little Dog are not Mean Animals
: 2. All Dogs are Animals
: 結論:
: Some dogs are mean
: 請問這樣推論是否合理?
: 網路上正確解答是 "不合理"
: 理由是:
: Minimal missing premise:
: It exists something that is dog and mean or dog and not animal
我會這樣畫:
┌──────────┐
│animals │
│┌────────┐│
││dogs ││
││┌──────┐││
│││little dog │││
│││┌────┐│││
││││not mean││││
│││└────┘│││
││└──────┘││
│└────────┘│
└──────────┘
--
: 1. Some Little Dog are not Mean Animals
: 2. All Dogs are Animals
: 結論:
: Some dogs are mean
: 請問這樣推論是否合理?
: 網路上正確解答是 "不合理"
: 理由是:
: Minimal missing premise:
: It exists something that is dog and mean or dog and not animal
我會這樣畫:
┌──────────┐
│animals │
│┌────────┐│
││dogs ││
││┌──────┐││
│││little dog │││
│││┌────┐│││
││││not mean││││
│││└────┘│││
││└──────┘││
│└────────┘│
└──────────┘
--
Tags:
推理遊戲
All Comments

By Linda
at 2009-07-10T14:59
at 2009-07-10T14:59

By Kumar
at 2009-07-11T05:49
at 2009-07-11T05:49

By Quintina
at 2009-07-14T13:07
at 2009-07-14T13:07

By Catherine
at 2009-07-16T09:13
at 2009-07-16T09:13

By Joseph
at 2009-07-19T19:10
at 2009-07-19T19:10
Related Posts
進階三段邏輯題

By Lucy
at 2009-07-05T02:42
at 2009-07-05T02:42
關於期望值 (承上篇) 平衡點存在?

By Isabella
at 2009-06-23T21:50
at 2009-06-23T21:50
關於期望值 (承上篇)

By Rae
at 2009-06-22T17:37
at 2009-06-22T17:37
關於期望值 (承上篇)

By Donna
at 2009-06-22T13:17
at 2009-06-22T13:17
關於期望值 (承上篇)

By Kama
at 2009-06-22T12:54
at 2009-06-22T12:54