請教一個Martial_Power的Power - TRPG

Genevieve avatar
By Genevieve
at 2009-02-21T09:50

Table of Contents

: 推 LiouKen:好!馬上寫信去幹勦他!!! XDDDDDDDD 02/20 11:29
: 推 LiouKen:英文不好orz 02/20 11:40

試著寫了一下,文法應是有誤,請諸位賢能幫忙修正。

My wise Lord

Last time you tell me that “the attack that Combat Challenge grants is
not an opportunity attack. A marked enemy who shifts and attack someone
other than my character, my fighter can attack for the shift and make a
basic attack for the attack that did not include me.” Is that truth?

The original answer:
“I should clarify the attack you make with Combat Challenge is a Melee
Basic Attack, not an opportunity attack. If a marked enemy shifts then
attacks someone other than your fighter, you would get to make a basic
melee attack for the shift, and a basic melee attack for the attack that
did not include you, providing the enemy is still within melee range after
shifting.”

Indeed, all of us know that “melee basic attack” is a standard action
as an at-will power (PHB 287). Moreover, in PHB 269 “actions on other
turns”, we can see there are only three types of actions we can do in
other character’s turn, opportunity actions, immediate actions, and free
actions.

At that text, the rule book express that a character only can do ONE
immediate action in ONE ROUND, and ONE opportunity action in ONE TURN.
If my fighter can respond TWO attack for a shift and an attack (because
of the Combat Challenge class feature), that means the melee basic attack
(from Combat Challenge) is free action?! Why it's "as a immediate action "
, but is free action?

If the attack I make with Combat Challenge is a Melee Basic Attack, not
an opportunity attack. How can I use a standard action several times in
other’s turn? Is that really a free action?

We hope to receive your favors at an early date.

Thanks for your answering

Yours sincerely reader

--
一整個亂寫...= =
--
《現世乃一夢,夜夢惟其真》

--
Tags: TRPG

All Comments

請教一個Martial_Power的Power

Hamiltion avatar
By Hamiltion
at 2009-02-20T03:38
: 所以答案是兩次,基本上應該要說只要能滿足Trigger,就可以無限次 : 雖然我個人對這個答案並非十分信服,覺得PHB文字敘述上有瑕疵 : 但是我想主要是因為對英文語意的語感不同為主因 : 官方回應中強調Combat Challenge is a Melee Basic Attack : 而後面的you ...

請教一個Martial_Power的Power

Elma avatar
By Elma
at 2009-02-19T13:09
※ 引述《LiouKen (小龜)》之銘言: : 非常高興的有人跟我的想法相同,不過這是錯的 : 之前與朋友討論OA跟Combat Challeng時他寫信問WotC,官方回應如下 : Q: does the fighter enjoy an and#34;extraand#34; attack of opp ...

請教一個Martial_Power的Power

Brianna avatar
By Brianna
at 2009-02-19T09:08
※ 引述《LiouKen (小龜)》之銘言: : 標題: Re: [問題] 請教一個Martial_Power的Power : 時間: Thu Feb 19 00:13:40 2009 : : : → lueur:第一個問題,見PHB p290 Interrupsts Targetand#39;s actio ...

請教一個Martial_Power的Power

Donna avatar
By Donna
at 2009-02-19T00:13
: → lueur:第一個問題,見PHB p290 Interrupsts Targetand#39;s action條 02/19 00:00 : 推 lueur:Interrupts Action是動作類別,指它會先於所觸發的動作,而 02/19 00:04 : 推 lueur:非中斷該動作 ...

請教一個Martial_Power的Power

Olga avatar
By Olga
at 2009-02-18T23:11
: → LuciferRT:每個敵人各自的回合你都有一下可以打 02/18 22:27 : → LuciferRT:如果像原文說「同一個回合」內有複數敵人那還是只有一下 02/18 22:28 說到opportunity attack我另外有兩個問題想問,以舉例的方 ...