古老的三門問題 但我找不到正解 - 推理遊戲
By Yuri
at 2006-05-04T00:33
at 2006-05-04T00:33
Table of Contents
推 crazyass:爭議很大,當初說是2/3的人,被美國許多數學教授指為錯誤 04/30 12:57
推 OoSaneoO:在哪看到說指為錯誤的??? 05/03 09:44
這個問題就是有名的 Monty Hall Problem
wiki可以查到相關資料
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Hall_problem
當初的爭議可以看這一段
=======================================================================
A restated version of Selvin's problem statement appeared in Marilyn
vos Savant's "Ask Marilyn" question-and-answer column of Parade
magazine in September 1990. Though vos Savant gave the correct answer
that switching would win 2/3rds of the time, vos Savant estimates
10,000 readers including several hundred mathematics professors wrote
in to declare that her solution was wrong. As a result of the publicity
the problem earned the alternative name Marilyn and the Goats.
=======================================================================
在1990年Marilyn vos Savant曾經在雜誌專欄裡提過這個問題,並給了換了之後
可以贏2/3的正確答案。不過之後卻接到了約一萬名讀者(其中包括幾百位數學教
授)聲稱這個答案是錯誤的來信。
--
Tags:
推理遊戲
All Comments
By Hardy
at 2006-05-04T15:24
at 2006-05-04T15:24
By Ivy
at 2006-05-07T01:21
at 2006-05-07T01:21
Related Posts
關於精華區中"到底是誰"這篇
By Emily
at 2006-05-03T22:33
at 2006-05-03T22:33
這題沒有體積 算得出來嗎?
By Wallis
at 2006-04-30T16:42
at 2006-04-30T16:42
古老的三門問題 但我找不到正解
By Belly
at 2006-04-29T02:19
at 2006-04-29T02:19
古老的三門問題 但我找不到正解
By Kama
at 2006-04-28T22:08
at 2006-04-28T22:08
條件機率 與 三門問題 ... 進來看看吧
By Callum
at 2006-04-27T18:45
at 2006-04-27T18:45