NPH FAQ的問題 - 魔法風雲會

Gilbert avatar
By Gilbert
at 2011-05-08T11:39

Table of Contents

: → georgehoug:能否告知是哪條規定能讓 異種接值第四點合理? 05/06 22:13
: → georgehoug:讚美詩與此卡皆屬靜止式效應 05/06 22:13
: → georgehoug:除非此條規則藏在裁判手冊 不然玩了這麼久還沒看過 05/06 22:13
: → georgehoug:規則有這樣搞的 05/06 22:13
: → georgehoug:在不看FAQ下 直接解釋的話根本不該有這樣的答案 05/06 22:14
: → georgehoug:MTG的規則是概述 而不是為每張單卡做新規則 05/06 22:14
: → georgehoug:這樣的話我跟脆去玩遊戲王算了 規則隨我說 05/06 22:15
呃……(嫌長的直接看下面紅字)

614.1c Effects that read "[This permanent] enters the battlefield with...,"
"As [this permanent] enters the battlefield...," or "[This permanent] enters
the battlefield as..." are replacement effects.

614.1d Continuous effects that read "[This permanent] enters the battlefield
..." or "[Objects] enter the battlefield..." are replacement effects.

614.12. Some replacement effects modify how a permanent enters the
battlefield. (See rules 614.1c–d.)
Such effects may come from the permanent itself if they affect only that
permanent (as opposed to a general subset of permanents that includes it).
They may also come from other sources. To determine which replacement effects
apply and how they apply, check the characteristics of the permanent as it
would exist on the battlefield, taking into account replacement effects
that have already modified how it enters the battlefield, continuous effects
generated by the resolution of spells or abilities that changed the
permanent's characteristics on the stack (see rule 400.7a), and continuous
effects from the permanent’s own static abilities, but ignoring continuous
effects from any other source that would affect it.

規則講得很清楚,不用再補充啥了吧。
==
所以梅莉萊是沒辦法讓蝕刻巨獸以10/10進場的
==
順帶一提沒有靜止式效應,只有靜止式異能

--
聽說把blog分類比較有人看 ._.a

主(雜)blog http://urakagi.blogspot.com/
日文blog http://urakagij.blogspot.com/
英文blog http://urakagie.blogspot.com/

--

All Comments

Heather avatar
By Heather
at 2011-05-10T22:17
真狠,還限定要結算的咒語或異能,難怪同謀沒用……
Ivy avatar
By Ivy
at 2011-05-11T01:34
樓上你在說什麼我不太懂
Eden avatar
By Eden
at 2011-05-11T05:48
同謀雖然會改變堆疊上生物咒語的類別
Leila avatar
By Leila
at 2011-05-14T02:52
但是不屬於結算的咒語或異能,所以竹林美範不吃
Margaret avatar
By Margaret
at 2011-05-16T02:30
ouch,瞭解,剛剛搞錯了

請問一下一些不小心挖出來的牌

Dora avatar
By Dora
at 2011-05-08T02:49
如題 最近找到很~~~久之前玩的 (遠目) 不知道現在的比賽還都可不可以用啊? 像是這什麼雄獅馬基塔 http://wowbox.tw/mtg/viewacard.php?CardID=24565 以前好像很威 還有什麼白木甲 祝福之風等等的 都還有沒有人在用啊 請教一下版上的各位 謝謝 呵呵 ...

New Phyrexia singles

Carol avatar
By Carol
at 2011-05-07T23:07
大家好~~ 高雄 台北 嘉義可約面交 其他地區掛號郵寄 Phyrexian Obliterator 非瑞克西亞抹煞獸 1C $550 Chancellor of the Tangle 綠督長 1C1E $30 Chancellor of the Dross 黑督長 1E $20 Phyrexian Sw ...

NPH FAQ的問題

Rosalind avatar
By Rosalind
at 2011-05-07T21:08
→ buffalobill:應該說是When跟As的問題,竹林美範沒寫,但是算As的 05/07 00:04 → georgehoug:我是認為這樣解釋才會比較合理 05/07 00:05 → georgehoug:用特徵值來說明有點太過... 05/07 00:05 → buffalobill:啊就As的時 ...

現開消失?

Queena avatar
By Queena
at 2011-05-07T16:26
※ 引述《artywu (我不是衰神)》之銘言: : 為了不要危言聳聽,直接發個文澄清一下: : 大約六、七年前的magic比賽幾乎都是地區主辦人──也就是我們所稱的TO所主辦的, : 店家能夠辦的比賽實在不多,例如FNM、Arena league等等。 : 而這幾年來地區主辦人手中的比賽數量越來越少,漸漸地 ...

台北象牙塔 5/14(六) 新生非瑞克西亞發售賽

Tracy avatar
By Tracy
at 2011-05-07T03:28
日期:5月14日(六) 地點:象牙塔桌上遊戲精品 台北市大同區五原路23號 地圖:http://tinyurl.com/64acn5x 交通方式: 雙連捷運站往承德路徒步五分鐘,到雙連派出所左轉即可 或可搭乘以下公車至民生西路口站下車,往承德路的小巷即為五原路 26,266,292,304承德路,518,81 ...