Live tournament 規則問題 - 撲克牌

By Rosalind
at 2010-07-06T13:21
at 2010-07-06T13:21
Table of Contents
我人在美國,今天參加了一個 30 人的 live tournament,前四名有錢。進
final table 後,有一牌 action 大約如下
UTG limp
UTG+1 all-in 5bb
兩家蓋掉
我 AJo call
CO BTN 大小盲 蓋掉
UTG call
這時 UTG+1 以為要開牌了,就伸手去開,被 dealer 阻止。我看到 UTG+1 拿
的是 AK,但 UTG 沒看到。因為是 jumbo index 的牌,所以看得很清楚。
flop 開 AKT 兩張同花。我的牌雖然輸了,但我願意打 side-pot,我就 bet
,UTG 蓋掉。turn 彈出一張 Q 來我就用狗屎運把對手送走了。
這牌過後,我跟旁邊的人聊天,說我當時有看到他的牌。結果 UTG 聽到了就
大暴走,說我當下就該馬上說,不說就是作弊,一直罵我,還把 floor 叫來,
有另一個玩家也一起起鬨。我說我根本不知道我當下就應該說,floor 則是跟
UTG 說已經過去的就過去了,並沒有另外跟我說什麼。
問題:我看到牌的當下,有義務要說嗎?或者是,理論上我應該說嗎?說了的
話,UTG+1 的牌會不會被打開?要是我看錯了的話怎麼辦?
我算是對自己道德要求比較高一點,如果道德上我應該開口,我會選擇開口。
但如果開口可能會惹麻煩上身的話 (例如不是 jumbo index 的牌看錯),我會選
擇不說。
--
If I don't know I don't know, I think I know
If I don't know I know, I think I don't know
── R. D. Laing
--
final table 後,有一牌 action 大約如下
UTG limp
UTG+1 all-in 5bb
兩家蓋掉
我 AJo call
CO BTN 大小盲 蓋掉
UTG call
這時 UTG+1 以為要開牌了,就伸手去開,被 dealer 阻止。我看到 UTG+1 拿
的是 AK,但 UTG 沒看到。因為是 jumbo index 的牌,所以看得很清楚。
flop 開 AKT 兩張同花。我的牌雖然輸了,但我願意打 side-pot,我就 bet
,UTG 蓋掉。turn 彈出一張 Q 來我就用狗屎運把對手送走了。
這牌過後,我跟旁邊的人聊天,說我當時有看到他的牌。結果 UTG 聽到了就
大暴走,說我當下就該馬上說,不說就是作弊,一直罵我,還把 floor 叫來,
有另一個玩家也一起起鬨。我說我根本不知道我當下就應該說,floor 則是跟
UTG 說已經過去的就過去了,並沒有另外跟我說什麼。
問題:我看到牌的當下,有義務要說嗎?或者是,理論上我應該說嗎?說了的
話,UTG+1 的牌會不會被打開?要是我看錯了的話怎麼辦?
我算是對自己道德要求比較高一點,如果道德上我應該開口,我會選擇開口。
但如果開口可能會惹麻煩上身的話 (例如不是 jumbo index 的牌看錯),我會選
擇不說。
--
If I don't know I don't know, I think I know
If I don't know I know, I think I don't know
── R. D. Laing
--
Tags:
撲克牌
All Comments

By Yuri
at 2010-07-11T11:19
at 2010-07-11T11:19

By Olga
at 2010-07-13T08:40
at 2010-07-13T08:40

By Ina
at 2010-07-14T20:36
at 2010-07-14T20:36

By Vanessa
at 2010-07-15T11:04
at 2010-07-15T11:04

By Candice
at 2010-07-16T18:02
at 2010-07-16T18:02

By Kristin
at 2010-07-17T00:21
at 2010-07-17T00:21

By Callum
at 2010-07-20T17:24
at 2010-07-20T17:24

By Mia
at 2010-07-23T03:00
at 2010-07-23T03:00

By Skylar Davis
at 2010-07-25T08:25
at 2010-07-25T08:25

By Margaret
at 2010-07-29T18:33
at 2010-07-29T18:33

By Mary
at 2010-08-02T01:48
at 2010-08-02T01:48

By Caroline
at 2010-08-06T06:09
at 2010-08-06T06:09

By Damian
at 2010-08-08T23:26
at 2010-08-08T23:26

By Eartha
at 2010-08-12T15:26
at 2010-08-12T15:26

By Elvira
at 2010-08-17T03:04
at 2010-08-17T03:04
Related Posts
don一問

By Hamiltion
at 2010-07-06T02:20
at 2010-07-06T02:20
由此可知Durrrr比Terry 高了不少....(Terry插花演出三秒)

By Edith
at 2010-07-04T16:49
at 2010-07-04T16:49
這樣打好嗎?

By Rosalind
at 2010-07-04T14:03
at 2010-07-04T14:03
這樣打好嗎?

By Carolina Franco
at 2010-07-04T11:32
at 2010-07-04T11:32
怎麼處理這手牌

By Jake
at 2010-07-04T03:55
at 2010-07-04T03:55